Merry Crustmas
Stuff stuffing, come and eat pizza this Christmas!
We've got you covered with our festive specials and group dining menus, perfect for celebrating with friends, fam or colleagues.
Kick off your Christmas with us!
Grab A Table







15 Carlton Street, Nottingham, NG1 1NL
We’re bringing a touch of Neapolitan flair to Nottingham and we’re genuinely glad to be here. Pizza Pilgrims on Carlton Street is the place for proper pizza in Nottingham: slow-proved dough, quality Italian ingredients and a pizzeria atmosphere that’s warm, lively and built for lingering.
Come for the pizza. Stay for the vibes. And if you fancy making a night of it, keep an eye out for The Dramattic, our secret upstairs events space with karaoke, FIFA and fancy dress. More on that below.
Sun - Weds: 12PM - 9PM
Thurs: 12PM - 10PM
Fri- Sat: 12PM - 11PM
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
FIFA
Karaoke & Fancy Dress
Stuff stuffing, come and eat pizza this Christmas!
We've got you covered with our festive specials and group dining menus, perfect for celebrating with friends, fam or colleagues.
Kick off your Christmas with us!
Grab A Table



Hiding upstairs is The Dramattic, Nottingham’s very own rave cave. It’s for the eccentric at heart: a fancy dress wall, foosball, a games console with SingStar karaoke and FIFA. The pizza is at the heart of it all, naturally, with our feasting menu served family-style and in abundance
The Dramattic is available for private hire, perfect for birthdays, work parties, group dinners or any occasion that needs a bit more character than a standard restaurant booking. Get in touch at nottingham@pizzapilgrims.co.uk to find out more.
Whether it’s a casual lunch, a Friday night out or a group dinner that runs longer than planned, Pizza Pilgrims Nottingham is set up for it. The menu covers vegetarian, vegan and halal options, gluten free bases are available, and the restaurant is family friendly throughout.
For groups of 8 or more, feasting menus make ordering for a crowd easy and enjoyable, a selection of pizzas served sharing-style so everyone gets a taste of everything. Bookings are available for those who like to plan ahead, and walk-ins are always welcome.
Book Now
Come and master the true art of pizza making at Pizza Pilgrims Nottingham.
Learn all about the Pizza Pilgrims story whilst enjoying our delicious Fritto Misto 🍘 Italian street food and a fizz / beer in hand.
Follow along the masterclass, guided by our best pizzaiolos 🍕and learn how to shape dough, create the perfectly balanced pizza and then, of course, how to master the art of baking it in our dome pizza oven.
Once your pizza is ready you’ll get to enjoy the fruits of your labour. And as the Italian saying goes "because life’s so bitter" our Chefs will make their signature Nutella Ring dessert to sweeten things up. 🍩
Book Now
Got a hungry crew? Planning a birthday? Gathering mates before a big night? Whatever the weather we got you.
Our Group Dining Pilgrimage Menus are built for sharing, celebrating and zero faff. No pre-orders, no stress, just great food landing on the table.
Book Now
Pizza Pilgrims started as a pilgrimage, literally. In 2012, our founders Thom and James quit their jobs, jumped in a three-wheel Piaggio van at the toe of Italy and drove 4,500km north, eating and learning everything they could about authentic Neapolitan pizza. That obsession is what’s been on the plate ever since.
At Nottingham, that means 72-hour double-fermented dough, San Marzano tomatoes, fior di latte mozzarella and a 500°C oven. Iconic Neapolitan pizzas alongside a few signatures worth getting to know: the double pepperoni & spicy honey is a crowd favourite, the mushroom & truffle is the one people come back for. Cold beers, cocktails and outdoor seating in summer round things off nicely.

Pizza Pilgrims Nottingham is on Carlton Street, right in the heart of the city. It’s the kind of place that’s easy to slot into your day, a proper sit-down lunch, a post-work dinner, a spontaneous pizza night. Nottingham pizza doesn’t need to be complicated. Sometimes you just want something made well, in a room with good energy.
If you’re looking for great pizza in Nottingham, here’s what you’ll find at Pizza Pilgrims: 72 hours double-fermented dough, Italian ingredients sourced for flavour rather than convenience, and a kitchen that takes the craft of Neapolitan pizza seriously. We’ve been making pizza this way since 2012, not because it’s the quickest route, but because it makes a genuine difference to what ends up in the box or on the plate.
Takeaway and Click & Collect are available, and delivery is available to postcodes across the local area. Or book a table and come in, the outdoor terrace is worth it when the weather plays along.

Neapolitan pizza has a protected tradition behind it, specific techniques, specific ingredients, ovens running at temperatures most home kitchens would find alarming. Pizza Pilgrims follows that tradition closely: ’00’ flour, San Marzano tomatoes DOP, Campanian fior di latte, 500°C heat. The result is a crust that’s light, pillowy and properly charred, just like the ones that started the whole pilgrimage in the first place.
Pizza Pilgrims is at 15 Carlton Street, NG1 1NL, open seven days a week. The pizza is made with slow-proved dough, DOP-certified Italian ingredients and baked at 500°C. Come and try it and see what you think. Walk-ins are welcome or book ahead.
Yes. Click & Collect is available directly through pizzapilgrims.orderswift.com/nottingham — order online and takeaway from Carlton Street. Delivery is also available across the local area. Check current delivery zones and the latest menu online.
Yes, bookings are available and a good idea for groups or busy evenings. Walk-ins are always welcome too. Book online or just come in.
Neapolitan pizza is defined by its technique: a soft, light dough that’s slow-proved over time, topped simply with quality ingredients and baked at very high heat, 500°C or above. That high temperature is what creates the characteristic blistered, charred crust and slightly chewy base. It’s a protected tradition originating in Naples, and the approach Pizza Pilgrims has followed since day one.
It’s a great spot for groups. Our pizzas are made for sharing and the restaurant is set up for it. For larger parties, feasting menus make it easy to feed a crowd with a mix of pizzas served family-style. The Dramattic, our upstairs events space, is also available for private hire, with karaoke, games and a feasting menu included. Get in touch at nottingham@pizzapilgrims.co.uk to discuss.